Thursday, April 19, 2007

Joslynn Trail

29 comments:

JoslynnTrail said...

Beowulf Criticism

The hero has been looked upon for centuries as a symbol of strength. From the earliest written documents stories have come forth of heroes and their adventures. In the eighth century an unknown poet scribed the story of Beowulf. Within it’s pages are tales of their hero, Beowulf, and his adventures. Throughout the use of weaponry and armor show the hero through an extension of their power. The Christian impact brings with it the divine power that enables the hero to beat his enemies with weapons and armor of infinite strength. The weapons and armor chosen by a hero, control his ultimate destiny.

The instance where Beowulf uses his hands to fight Grendal and ultimately kill him. Beowulf remembers that all power "lay in god’s hands," therefore he does not pickup his sword, this fight would be undertaken with his brute strength. "Our holy father had sent [Beowulf] as a sign of his grace, a mark of his favor, to help us defeat Grendal and end tha...

JoslynnTrail said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
JoslynnTrail said...

Beowulf is one of the oldest existing poems in the English Language. Beowulf is an Anglo-Saxon epic poem, which portrays a story of an epic hero destined to defeat a ferocious monster in order to save a kingdom from destruction and death. The major theme in this epic was the theme of good versus evil. The theme of good versus evil was portrayed through the people and things that represented good and evil, which helped portray the theme throughout that novel, and explained the overall effect of this theme on the poem as a piece of literature.
There are many symbols that represent good in Beowulf. Beowulf himself is a symbol of good in this epic. Beowulf is tamed and civilized which are the characteristics of goodness and purity. First off, Beowulf is pure and shows this before his battle when he removes his armor, and vows not to use a weapon to defeat Grendel. Defeating Grendel, he shows that man, without armor and weapons, can defeat evil in any form including that of his enemy Grendel. This serves as a symbol of Beowulf's Goodness. Another symbol of goodness is light. Light symbolizes day and rejoicing. When light, such as the sun and moon, are showing it gives people a sense of comfort and t

. . .
Therefore, this symbolized another good versus evil battle. " In this description of Herot after Grendel's massacres, Hrothgar describes the mead-hall as "glittering, with new light” which would be drenched with blood. hey don’t seem to be scared of daylight. So, in the end of this final battle, it was good and evil that perished. But as his shield was melting, the dragon injected poison into Beowulf’s neck, which injected him with poison, thus killing Beowulf. Everything went well for fifty years, until a stranger stole a chastise from a dragon’s lair. But when Beowulf came to Herot there was more goodness. Therefore, the good overcame the evil. As a result, he killed the dragon but also died in the process. So Beowulf, still feeling triumphant about killing Grendel, set off for Grendel’s mother. And then, in the morning, this mead-hall glittering, with new light would be drenched with blood, the benches, stained red, the floors, all wet from that fiend's savage assault-and my soldiers would be fewer still death taking more and more. Wiglaf showed goodness by helping Beowulf defeat the dragon when the others would not. So when Grendel attacked Herot that night, it was Beowulf and Grendel fighting it off. Then all of the people in the kingdom of Herot danced, feasted, and rejoiced for the rest of the night.


In Beowulf, the theme of good versus evil was used widely throughout the epic poem.

JoslynnTrail said...

The first article talks about Beowulf being a sign sent from god? And thats how he killed Beowulf by his bare hands. However it cost money to see the rest but there is a little bit of criticism.

JoslynnTrail said...

Reader Response
This critics criticism is kind of all over the place. But,

Jessica Crum said...

Beowuld is symbolic of strenght and this is seem all over the text. When she is able to slay Grendel and free the worlf from his rather, he proves his emince strenght.

Jack Roche said...

Beowulf is symbolizes strength in many parts of the story. He killed two monsters and a dragon throughout his life. That shows that he symbolizes strength.

Phil Coyne said...

(Refering to the first article)From this critic's point of view, I can agree that the Epic of Beowulf was written in a sense to emphasise Christianity. The poem has a powerful Christian influence throughout, emphasizing that god is the main influence of the universe. Beowulf does point out that his power laid within the hands of god, essentially saying that god chose for him to have the strength to defeat evil. However the author brings up that a hero will control his own destiny by using weapons and armor rather than a divine being. I suppose the author means that the poet believed that Christian values will greatly aid the hero, while a person can control their own destiny....

Tabitha Dunklin said...

I agree with the author of this critic in the story of Beowulf "StReNgth"is symbolized well through Beowulf. Beowulf not only defeats Grendal but has conquered victory in all the battles before and after Grendal, and that takes strength.

Dylan Bernard said...

In response to the first critic, I do not beleive that Boewulf's weapons are what enables him to slay beasts. The critic himself even says later that he lays down his weapons and kills Grendel with his bare hands, refuting his original statement.

Kevin Bates said...

I agree with Dylan, to state that the hero controls his (her) own destiny by the weapons they choose seems to directly conflict with Beowulf's claims as he grapples with Grenel and his Dam.

The second essay seems to focus on the symbolism that Beowulf reprents the "perfect" hero of the middle ages, which seems appropriate for an ancient folktale.

Zach Augustine said...

Beowulf is a true hero. He uses his weapons and armor as tools but realizes when it comes down to it, they are just tools. He kills Grendel with his hands to prove that God gave him weapons that get the job done. I agree with the article if its a debateable issue...

Richard said...

Beowulf definately symbolizes strentgth. He defeats Grendal with his bare hands because it is believed that the power lie within Gods hands. Beowulf also defeats others along the way.

Brandon said...

There is one statement by the author that I found confusing: "Beowulf is tamed and civilized which are the characteristics of goodness and purity..."
Well, from what I read, Beowulf tore apart Grendel with his bare hands. This is not my vision of "tamed and civilized."

Unknown said...

I agree with the author of this criticism. Beowulf is a symbol of strength, he defeated two monsters and won many victories in his life time. He also was strong enough to kill Grendel with his bare hands. This proves some kind of strength.

The Real Ayao S. said...

I would definetly have to agree with richard about the first cristism that Beowulf symbolizes strenght. With his strenght giving by god he is able to defeat all of his enemies.

The Incredible Ben Reid said...

Beowulf is the epitomy of the word brave. He slays Grendel with his bare hand the later defeats the troll-wife and the dragon.

$cott Earl said...

I agree that Beowulf symbolizes strength throughout the book. He not only defeats Grendel, but also Grendel's mother and the dragon.

Chanel Riser said...

Responding to the first article, weapons are not the tool that allows Beowulf to defeat others. In the text it tells us that Beowulf slays Grendel with his bare hands which obviously contradicts the opinion of the critic.

Kelly! [at the disco] said...

In response to the author's thoughts on how heroes are almost always percieved as strong, I think that heroes dont always need weapons to prevail over evil, much like Beowulf did when fighting Grendel.

brittany gentilini said...

Beowulf shows strength through out the story. Although he did die in the end, he made a good impact while he was alive. Killing grendel, the troll wife, and the Dragon, his time on earth was put to good use.

Steven Marconi said...

Indeed Beowulf does have weapons, however he does not use them to win battles. He relies on his own strength to finsh his fights. The article talks about how he kills Grendal with his bare hands, And if that doesnt symbolize strength i dont know what does.

monicak said...

I agree that Beowulf stood as a symbol of strength, as seen through his battle with Grendel, whom he slayed with his bare hands, instead of opting to use a sword.

Lauren Haller said...

I agree that good v. evil was a recurring theme in the text. The response is short and the evidence could definitely be lengthened, but what is given is fairly convincing.

KICHERER said...

I dont agree the the poet meant for Beowulf to be some kind of saint enabled by a Christian god. There are references to Christianity through out the text, but based on the articles we have read, it seems that this poem could have been written durring a time of religious turmoil. I always kinda figured that the author just threw that stuff in there to make the text more Christian so he wouldnt get in trouble.

Eric Riger said...

I agree that the weaponry that Beowulf used was an extenstion of his power. He was given a sacred sword to fight off Grendel and his mother. It showed his power and ability to use such an important sword. Also, good and evil is definietly a theme in Beowulf.

Kirsten Albers-Fiedler said...

Beowulf carries a definitive strength far greater than any armor could provide. The use of his bare hand reveals his true strength.

Joslynn Trail said...

Geoffrey Chaucer began writing The Canterbury Tales sometime around 1387 A.D.; the uncompleted manuscript was published in 1400, the year he died. Having recently passed the six hundredth anniversary of its publication, the book is still of interest to modern students for several reasons. For one thing, The Canterbury Tales is recognized as the first book of poetry written in the English language. Before Chaucer’s time, even poets who lived in England wrote in Italian or Latin, which meant that poetry was only understandable to people of the wealthy, educated class. English was considered low class and vulgar. To a great degree, The Canterbury Tales helped make it a legitimate language to work in. Because of this work, all of the great writers who followed, from Shakespeare to Dryden to Keats to Eliot, owe him a debt of gratitude. It is because Chaucer wrote in English that there is a written record of the roots from which the modern language grew. Contemporary readers might find his words nearly as difficult to follow as a foreign language, but scholars are thankful for the chance to compare Middle English to the language as it is spoken now, to examine its growth.

In the same way that The Canterbury Tales gives modern readers a sense of the language at the time, the book also gives a rich, intricate tapestry of medieval social life, combining elements of all classes, from nobles to workers, from priests and nuns to drunkards and thieves. The General Prologue alone provides a panoramic view of society that is not like any found elsewhere in all of literature. Students who are not particularly interested in medieval England can appreciate the author’s technique in capturing the variations of human temperament and behavior. Collections of stories were common in Chaucer’s time, and some still exist today, but the genius of The Canterbury Tales is that the individual stories are presented in a continuing narrative, showing how all of the various pieces of life connect to one another.

Jillian Winkler said...

Beowulf symbolizes strength in many parts of the story. He killed two monsters and a dragon throughout his life.